Item
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Individual project preparation, research & analysis
|
Missing major elements; significant deadlines missed or ignored; poor or non-existent preparation; haphazard or poor research; analysis weak or non-existent |
All elements represented but need work; deadlines generally met; preparation planned to some extent; some research; analysis incomplete or needs revision |
All elements complete but more documentation needed; all deadlines just met; preparation adequate; analysis complete, but needs some clarification or revision |
All elements complete and neatly documented; thoroughly researched; deadlines met or exceeded; preparation exceptional and thorough; analysis exceptional and complete |
Individual project paperwork, supporting documentation, renderings & drawings
|
Incomplete or missing paperwork; poor or irrelevant supporting documentation; missing or poorly executed renderings & drawings |
Most paperwork complete; some supporting documentation; renderings and drawings could use revisions or re-working, but generally workable |
Paperwork complete but needs minor revisions; supporting documentation adequate; renderings and drawings could use minor revisions , but workable |
All paperwork, supporting documentation, and renderings precise, neat, complete; deadlines always met. |
Individual finished product, design, or assignment
|
Lacks style, coherence, or relevance; missing elements; poor quality and poor presentation |
Clear attempt at a specific style; lacks coherence; all elements represented but need work; quality is ok; presentation is ok |
Clearly a specific style; has general coherence; all elements represented but could be revised; quality is good; presentation is acceptable |
Complete and insightful design; creative and consistent style; exceptional quality; professional presentation |
Individual implementation process, technique, or results
|
Failed to complete major elements; deadlines missed; process carry-through incomplete, haphazard, or non-existent |
Most major elements completed to some degree; most deadlines met; process generally acceptable but more detail needed |
All major elements completed with some better than others; all deadlines generally met; process acceptable; needs minor revisions |
Includes all elements and then some; met/exceeded all deadlines; complete and thorough process and follow-up |
Portfolio, resume and supporting documentation for individual projects
|
Unorganized; lacking whole projects; resume missing; portfolio sloppy |
All projects represented but some elements missing; resume needs minor updating; some care with organization of portfolio |
All projects represented, some need minor work; resume needs minor work but is updated; port-folio clean, but needs minor work |
All projects and elements represented; excellent current resume; clear and well organized portfolio; great presentation |